Disability Benefits: Too Little, Too Late?

Can you depend on disability payments when you need them?

Suffering an accident or illness that results in permanent disability is life-altering as well as traumatic. Most people are under the impression that here, in the United States of America, we can count on our government to help us when we become unable to support ourselves and our families. Unfortunately, while the Social Security Administration has a well-established program to provide benefits to workers who have become disabled, bureaucracy gets in the way of processing those benefits in a timely manner. As a result, more than 1 million Americans wait an average of almost 2 years (longer than some of them will live!) to get a hearing that will decide whether they are eligible for benefits.

Delays Built into the System

Most applicants for disability benefits are denied coverage at least once, so they will, almost certainly, spend time waiting, first for a rejection, and then for an appeals hearing. In the meantime, they may use up savings, borrow at high interest rates, lose their homes or have to declare bankruptcy. This awful scenario need not be the case. If you find yourself in need of disability benefits, it is essential that you engage the services of a competent disability attorney who has the experience and the clout to navigate the system efficiently and effectively. Having a knowledgeable professional at your side can make a tremendous difference in getting your case handled more quickly and in getting positive results.

How Social Security Disability (SSD) Works

Unlike veterans’ benefits and workers’ compensation which grant awards according to percentages of disability, in order to be awarded SSD benefits, you must be considered completely disabled, not only unable to perform the duties of your previous position. If you are unable to perform your previous job, officials will evaluate whether you can adapt to a new type of employment.

The government defines complete disability as disability lasting at least a year or expected to result in death. Also, to receive SSD, rather than SSI benefits, applicants over the age of 31 must have accumulated a total of 20 work credits within the past 15 years. The only other way you can be eligible for SSD is if you are the unmarried child (under the age of 18) of a disabled parent, a full-time student up to the age of 19 (no higher than grade 12) of such a parent, or have yourself become disabled before the age of 22. If you are not entitled to SSD because you have never worked and don’t fit into any of the previous categories, you still may be eligible to claim disability through the SSI program if you are found to be medically disabled and also have limited income and resources.

How Much Will Social Security Pay if You Become Disabled?

If and when you are awarded SSD benefits, you should not expect the payments you receive to pay all your bills or to support your family. Though Social Security pays out almost $200 billion in disability payments to about 10.5 million people annually, the average recipient receives a check for only $1037 per month, not enough for a single individual to survive on, let alone a family.


Efforts To Improve the System

The Social Security Administration reports that it is working hard to reduce the dangerous backlog of disabled individuals who, in spite of dire need, are not yet receiving benefits. Efforts to remedy the situation include hiring 500 new administrative law judges and more than 600 new support staff members. These judges are expected to join the current 1600 judges who hear appeals from those who were initially denied benefits.

 

In addition, the agency is attempting to expand a program that will move more quickly to award benefits to individuals with the most serious conditions and illnesses, including certain cancers. Nonetheless, budget cuts over the past few years have interfered with the progress of this plan.

An illustration is that the agency’s budget for 2017 was $12.6 billion, about the same as it was in 2011, even though during the intervening years an additional 6 million people are receiving either retirement or disability benefits from Social Security.

Don’t Wait Too Long to Seek Legal Counsel
For some, the benefits come too late. Believe it or not, last year 7,400 people whose names were still on waitlists for SSD benefits had already died. When the two-thirds of original applicants for assistance have their claims denied by state agencies, they can ask the same state agencies to reconsider, though usually to no avail. The next step for people in most states is to file an appeal with an administrative law judge. At this point, the backlog of cases increases to 1.1 million applicants waiting for a hearing. Though this year there has been a slight decrease in those waiting, the number is 31 percent higher than it was in 2012.

Don’t lose out on disability benefits you need and deserve. Get in touch with a skilled Social Security Disability attorney who has a comprehensive knowledge of the the laws surrounding SSD benefits and the agility to move you through the process as quickly as possible.

How Might a Repeal of the Affordable Care Act Impact the Disabled in Arizona?

Although recent efforts to repeal the Affordable Care Act (also known as “Obamacare”) in favor of what has been promised to be a better national healthcare system have failed to pass to date, some Arizonans are worried about the fall out that may follow any plan that cuts services. In particular, the 1.9 Million people covered by Arizona’s version of Medicaid – – the Arizona Health Care Cost Containment System (“AHCCCS”)—stand to lose a lot.

How will this affect those receiving or applying for disability benefits in Arizona?

The federal government offers two different disability insurance and benefits programs. Social Security Disability Insurance (“SSDI”) is a work credits-based program available to individuals who meet the government’s definition of “disabled” and who previously paid into the Social Security system through income tax deductions for a certain length of time. In contrast, Supplemental Security Income (“SSI”) is a mean-tested program available to those with extremely limited financial resources who are of advanced age or are disabled. Depending on your particular situation, you and your family members may qualify for either program or both. In addition, pending on your situation, you and your family may qualify for health care coverage through the government’s Medicaid or Medicare programs.

What does the face of the potential crisis among disability benefits recipients in Arizona look like? Consider a single Arizona woman unable to work due to a debilitating condition known as Complex Regional Pain Syndrome who is raising two significantly disabled young children on food stamps and her SSDI payments. Her and her children’s exorbitant medical care costs, including a feeding tube and about 24 medications among the three of them, are covered through AHCCCS.  She fears her children will “be lost” if her medical benefits are cut. She is not alone, as 42% of those covered by AHCCCS are children under 17.

The AHCCCS system has been recognized as a “highly efficient” model of healthcare for other states, yet 74% of its expenditures are paid by federal funds which may be in jeopardy if the Affordable Care Act is repealed. AHCCCS differs from other states’ Medicaid programs in that it reimburses insurance companies based on the number of people they ensure rather than the number of health services provided.

If the federal funding is cut, not only may Arizonans lose their coverage, but hospitals may lay off workers to offset lost federal money. In addition, funds that would be allocated to services such as education and transportation infrastructure may need to be diverted to partially fill the void in healthcare funding. Further, if people need to use personal funds for healthcare costs, the local economy may be negatively impacted by reduced consumer spending.

While the future of the Affordable Care Act is not in your control, finding the right attorney to assist you with SSDI and SSI benefits applications and appeals is.

If you need assistance applying for SSDI benefits, SSI benefits, or appealing a denial of benefits, the disability attorneys of Arizona at Roeschke Law can help. Contact us for a free initial consultation and assessment of your claim. From our offices in Phoenix, Tucson, and Tempe, we represent clients throughout Arizona.

Disability Insurance Appeal Backlog Time Skyrockets

 

Q: How long does it take to get a federal disability benefits appeal hearing date?

Getting it right the first time you are applying for Social Security disability benefits is critical because the appeals process for denials is excruciatingly-long and it’s getting longer each day.

The federal government offers two different disability programs: Social Security Disability Insurance (“SSDI”) and Supplemental Security Income (“SSI”). Both require that an applicant meet the government’s definition of “disabled”, but the similarities end there.

To oversimplify a very complex topic, SSDI is a work-based program available to certain applicants who, in addition to meeting other qualifying criteria, previously worked and paid into the Social Security system through their payroll taxes for the requisite number of work years and work credits.

In contrast, SSI awards do not require any work history, but are need-based and only available to those who, in addition to meeting other qualifying criteria, have extremely limited economic situations. Sometimes applicants may be eligible for both benefits programs, so seeking advice from an Arizona disability insurance attorney on how to apply is advisable.

Not only can a social security disability attorney counsel you regarding which benefits to apply for, they know how to put the strongest and most complete initial application together– which may increase the chances of it being granted the first time around.

Why is it important to have the initial application granted?

Here are some frightening statistics to answer that question:

  • initial application decisions take an average of 4 months
  • only 1/3 of initial applications are approved
  • reconsideration decisions take another 4 months
  • only 12% of reconsiderations are approved
  • only 46% of people who apply for a hearing win.

And the most sobering statistic of all: “from the date of their initial application, many people end up waiting for 2 1/2 years or longer for a judge’s decision.”

That means that those who have been denied twice are then waiting about 596 days or 19 1/2 months for a hearing with a judge–among a backlog of cases estimated at 1.1 million. And while retroactive benefits are available to those who do ultimately win on appeal, that’s hardly a consolation to those disabled applicants struggling financially for so long.

Can you afford to wait that long?

Not only is the physical or mental disability hard on the applicant and their family, but the financial burden caused by the wait for benefits is unbearable for most. By hiring a skilled attorney whose practice is devoted exclusively to helping people secure federal disability benefits, an applicant can increase the likelihood of a successful initial application and expedite the application and/or appeals process. They also unburden themselves from the complicated paperwork and red tape of the process.

If you or a loved one is applying for Social Security disability benefits or is appealing a denial of your initial application, the Social Security disability experts at Roeschke Law can help you. Contact us for a free consultation.

From our offices in Phoenix, Tucson, and Tempe, we represent disabled clients and veterans throughout Arizona.

 

 

Social Security Disability vs. Long-term Disability Insurance

Q: Do I need Long-term Disability insurance if there is Social Security Disability insurance?

No one wants to think about becoming disabled and being unable to provide for yourself or your family financially, because the prospect is frightening and applying for long-term disability benefits is complicated. However, 1 in 4 people will suffer a long-term disability during their lifetime and the average length of a long-term disability is 2 1/2 years. Can any among us survive financially with medical bills and no income for 30 consecutive months?

Arizona disability insurance attorneys are knowledgeable in all aspects of Long-term Disability (“LTD”) insurance as well as Social Security Disability (“SSDI”) insurance and Supplemental Security Income (“SSI”) programs and can help with filing and appealing denials of all of these benefits.  

Some employees have Short-term Disability (“STD”) insurance and/or LTD through their employers. If you become disabled and can’t do your job, STD insurance generally covers you during the first 30 to 120 days. LTD generally kicks in after STD insurance is exhausted and may last a number of years or through retirement age, depending on the policy’s terms. If it’s not offered through an employer, workers can purchase their own LTD policy, but STD policies can’t be purchased privately, so building a nest-egg to cover the initial disability period is advisable if possible.

SSDI and SSI are two very different government programs designed to financially assist the disabled. While they are similar in defining what constitutes “disabled”, the other program qualifications differ. In a nutshell, SSDI benefits are work – based, meaning they are only available to people who have worked and paid into the Social Security system for the required number of years and hours before becoming disabled. In contrast, SSI benefits are means– based and are generally available to those with extremely limited financial resources and who are of advanced age or disabled. Some people qualify for both SSDI and SSI benefits.

The government’s definition of “disabled” for purposes of qualifying for SSDI or SSI is as follows: “a person is disabled if here she suffers from a physical or mental impairment that prevents engaging in substantial gainful activities and that has lasted, or is expected to last, for 12 months or more or result in death.”  LTD policies may define “disabled” differently.  And many LTD policies require the holder to apply for SSDI and/or SSI and may then reduce the percentage of LTD benefits if government benefits are granted. SSDI and SSI benefits are not guaranteed and, even if received, may be less than the amount available through a customizable LTD policy.

Both LTD claims and SSDI/SSI claims involve submitting often-complicated and extensive medical and other documentation and can take months in the best-case scenario or even years, depending on the appeals process. That’s why many hire a skilled disability attorney who understands the process and can often expedite moving a claim through the system.

If you or a loved one is disabled and needs assistance filing an initial claim for or appealing a denial of Social Security disability or long-term disability benefits, Roeschke Law can help you. Call us today at 800-975-1866 for a free consultation. From our offices in Phoenix, Tempe, and Tucson, we fight to get disabled clients throughout Arizona the benefits they deserve.

The Social Security Disability Insurance Appeals Process

Q: If I win a Social Security Disability Insurance appeal, are my benefits retroactive?

If you thought that applying for Social Security Disability Insurance benefits was complicated and time-consuming, wait until you hear about what’s involved in appealing a SSDI or SSI denial in Arizona in the event your initial application is denied.

If you are unable to work, you may qualify for one of the federal government’s two disability benefits programs – – Social Security Disability Insurance (“SSDI”) or Supplemental Security Income (“SSI”). Both programs are different, but each requires the applicant to meet the Social Security Administration’s definition of “disabled” which is “suffering from a physical or mental impairment that prevents engaging in substantial gainful activities and that has lasted, or is expected to last, for 12 months or more or result in death.” Some people may qualify for both benefits programs, depending on their particular situation.

A skilled disability law attorney will be able to help you with the complex application as well as determining which program to apply for. In general, SSDI is a work-based program available only to those who have paid into the Social Security system through income tax contributions over a required period of time before they became disabled.  The other disability program, SSI, is a means-based program generally available to those of extremely limited financial resources and are of advanced age or disabled.

Appealing an SSDI or SSI denial in Arizona can be up to a four-step appeals process depending on how many unfavorable rulings may be made along the way. It is important that you don’t miss the deadline for filing an appeal.

The 4 stages of the appeals process are:

Stage 1: Request for Reconsideration. Where a third party reviews the initial application and decision. If denied again, move on to stage 2.

Stage 2:  Hearing by an Administrative Law Judge. Information and medical evidence is exchanged and made part of the administrative record before the hearing.  During the hearing, witnesses are questioned and additional documents may be submitted. Then the Judge will either affirm or overturn the denial. If affirmed, move to stage 3.

Stage 3: The Social Security Appeals Council Review Request. The Appeals Council can review the record and grant the benefits or send the case back down for another hearing.  They can also agree with the denial, refusing to review the case at all. If you fail here, move to the final stage.

Stage 4: Start a Federal lawsuit. This Court’s decision is the final outcome of your claim.

As you can see, the initial application as well as the multiple levels of the appeals process can take an enormous amount of time. And during that time, the applicant and their family is likely struggling financially waiting for those benefits. Having Disability Attorneys of Arizona on your side may make the difference in receiving benefits or not. Fortunately, retroactive benefits are available if your application or appeal is granted.

If you are unable to work and are anywhere in the Social Security Disability application or appeals process, Roeschke Law can help you. Call us at 800-975-1866 for a free initial consultation and assessment of your claim. From our offices in Phoenix, Tempe, and Tucson, we represent disabled clients throughout Arizona.

Social Security Disability Benefits Vulnerable to New Budget Cuts

Q: How will President Trump’s proposed budget affect Social Security disability benefits?

Federal safety net programs such as Social Security Disability Insurance (“SSDI”) and Supplemental Security Income (“SSI”) and others can expect significant cuts and reforms if President Trump’s proposed budget passes in its current form, Social Security Disability lawyers warn.

The disability benefits legal experts are watching with interest for not only how the changes will impact those applying for SSDI disability benefits but also for any limitations on or cuts to the amounts of benefits disabled recipients are currently receiving.

The message from the top is “get a job, not a government handout”.  In an effort to cut down on fraud that is presumed to be widespread in government safety net programs and to encourage self-sufficiency, The White House Budget Director warned “if you are on disability insurance and you’re not supposed to be, if you are not truly disabled, we need you to go back to work.”

Forcing those who are able to work back to the workforce will not only cut back on the amount of money paid out to those no-longer-disabled-and-actually-employable workers who are milking the system, but they will again be paying into the system to support the future claims of legitimately-disabled workers.

In addition to SSDI, there will be cuts and or changes other programs which impact the disabled such as Medicaid and the Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program, (“SNAP”).

The proposed budget “would cut $72 billion by reforming disability programs”. The monthly benefits for the 10.6 million SSDI recipients total $11 billion. Reforms would focus on cracking down on recipients who are “exaggerating the extent of their ailment or staying on the program after they recover” by getting more enrollees off SSDI and back to work”.

Few would disagree with this concept on paper, but what will the reality of its implementation look like? Only time will tell. Meanwhile, honest people currently receiving disability benefits for legitimate and ongoing disabilities may be understandably uneasy about how the methods to root out the so-called fraudulent recipients may negatively impact the continuation of their rightful disability benefits.

If you need help applying for Social Security disability benefits or with appealing a denial of your application for benefits, the Social Security disability experts at Roeschke Law can help you at any stage of the process. Call us at 800-975-1866 for a free initial consultation and assessment of your claim.

Our Social Security lawyers represent clients in all counties and cities in Arizona from our offices in Phoenix, Tempe, and Tucson.

Extra Benefits Available to Social Security Disability Recipients

Q: Can my student loans be forgiven if I receive Social Security disability benefits?

Facing a disability is frightening. It could happen to any of us at any time through an illness or an injury. In addition to being painful, long-term disabilities are often accompanied by stress over providing for our families. Specifically, we worry about paying mounting bills for basic things like food and shelter and other bills like student loans.

Social Security disability attorneys can help those who have become disabled obtain government benefits like Social Security disability insurance (“SSDI”) or Supplemental Security Income (“SSI”). An experienced attorney can help streamline the rigorous administrative process of applying for disability benefits.

SSDI benefits are available to those under 65 who satisfy the government’s definition of “disabled” and who have accumulated the required minimum number of work credits prior to becoming disabled. Essentially, the person must’ve worked for a certain number of hours for a certain number of years and paid into the Social Security system through payroll taxes in order to qualify for SSDI. The disability can be physical or mental or both. A person is considered “disabled” if they “suffer from a physical or mental impairment that prevents engaging in substantial gainful activities and that has lasted, or is expected to last, for 12 months or more or result in death.”

Unlike SSDI, SSI is a needs–based program for those who are either over 65, blind, or disabled and who have extremely limited financial resources. Sometimes people may qualify for both disability benefit programs.

In addition to helping you through the disability benefits application process or handling a disability benefits appeal, a skilled attorney devoted to practicing disability law can advise you about other benefits you might be entitled to as a disabled person.

One such a benefit is the forgiveness of certain federal student loans in the case of a total and permanent disability. That means Social Security disability benefit recipients may be able to have the balance of their unpaid federal student loans forgiven—a potentially huge relief for those already financially challenged by an unexpected permanent and total disability, especially given the increasingly high costs of a college education.

In related news, legislation has been proposed that would offer similar federal student loan forgiveness to veterans who become totally and permanently disabled and unemployable due to a service-connected condition. The legislation is aimed at cutting “bureaucratic red tape” and proactively identifying and notifying veterans who have incurred a total and permanent disability and also have outstanding federal student loans that they are eligible to have those loans discharged.

If you need assistance applying for Social Security disability benefits or appealing a denial of those benefits, the disability attorneys at Roeschke Law can help you. Call us today at 800-975-1866 from our offices in Phoenix, Tempe, and Tucson, we represent disabled clients throughout Arizona.

Accessing Healthcare and Social Security Disability Insurance Benefits in Arizona

Q. If applied for Social Security Disability Insurance benefits, can I also qualify for health care coverage?

The first thing a worker who becomes disabled and unable to work worries about is paying the bills without a paycheck. That’s why disabled workers should immediately seek counsel from a Social Security Disability Insurance Benefits attorney and apply for Social Security Disability Insurance (“SSDI”) benefits. Don’t delay, because the process takes several months at best.

How does a disabled worker qualify for SSDI benefits?

Basically, SSDI is available to workers under the age of 65 who have worked and paid into the Social Security system through their payroll taxes for a minimum specified number of hours and years and who satisfy the Social Security Administration’s definition of “disabled”. It is based on the worker’s income, not need, but is designed to cover basic living expenses, not a full replacement of lost income.

Next, a disabled worker may worry about loss of health coverage.

If you are collecting Social Security Disability Insurance (“SSDI”) benefits in Arizona, the good news is that you automatically qualify for Medicare.  But the bad news is you have to wait 29 months–almost 3 years –from the onset of your disability in order to become Medicare eligible. This date is generally two years after receipt of your first SSDI benefits check.

What is a disabled worker without health insurance to do for health care coverage during that 2 year+ period?

Well, there is some interim good news as well.

Arizona has its own Medicaid program called AHCCCS which can “act a bridge to Medicare” because it helps pay medical expenses for qualified disabled people with low enough incomes during that 29-month waiting period for Medicare to kick in.

Once you’re on SSDI and Medicare, you might qualify for AHCCCS under disability rather than “income-only” rules if you have little or no other income besides your SSDI benefits and “if your monthly SSDI cash benefit is less than 100% of the Federal Poverty Guidelines ($1005 per month for an individual, $1353 for a couple)”. AHCCCS may also be available to those who are collecting SSDI and also working through AHCCCS Freedom to Work.

If you live in Arizona and need assistance applying for Social Security Disability Insurance or Supplemental Security Income (“SSI”), the Social Security disability law experts at Roeschke Law can help you at any phase of the application or appeals process.

Call us at 800-975-1866 for a free consultation. From our offices in Phoenix, Tucson, and Tempe, we represent clients in all areas of disability law throughout the state of Arizona. 

Returning to Work While Collecting Social Security Disability Insurance Benefits

Q: If I return to work, will I immediately lose my Social Security Disability Insurance benefits?

A common question Social Security Disability benefits attorneys often hear from clients who are either applying for disability benefits or are already receiving benefits is “What will happen to my benefits if I return to work?”.

Social Security Disability Insurance (“SSDI”) benefits is an income-based federal benefits program. In order to qualify for SSDI benefits, an applicant must be younger than 65 years of age, satisfy the minimum number of work credits, and meet the Social Security Administration’s (“SSA”) definition of “disabled”. Work credits are earned based on a formula under which workers need to work a minimum number of hours for a minimum number of years while paying payroll tax taxes into the Social Security system. SSDI is granted for both physical and mental disabilities provided the disability is serious, long-term, and possibly terminal in nature, again as outlined in the SSA’s legal definition.

While SSDI benefits are long-term in nature, they are not always permanent. Sometimes recipients upon future review may be determined to no longer qualify as disabled. More common perhaps is the situation where a recipient may be recovering and may want to try to return to the workforce. It is this situation where people fear losing their SSDI benefits only to find but they aren’t able to handle the return to the workforce.

If this is you, the Social Security Administration has your back.

The Social Security Administration, in an effort to encourage benefits recipients to attempt to return to work when they feel they are able to do so, has established a 3-step program. Here are the basics, in a nutshell.

In the first step, known as the Trial Work Period (“TWP”), workers are able to return to work and receive their full SSDI benefits regardless of how much salary they earn for up to a nine-month period.

Step two begins when the Trial Work Period ends. It’s called the three-year Extended Period of Eligibility (“EPE”). What, if any, benefits you are entitled to depends on whether you earn more or less than the current Substantial Gainful Activity (“SGA”) level established by SSA. For 2017, the SGA level is $1,170. So, during this three-year period of working, you are eligible for SSDI benefits for each month you earn less than the SGA level.

The third and final step of the return to work program is called the Expedited Reinstatement Period. This five-year period begins when the three-year EPE period has ended. If it anytime during this five-year period your earnings fall below the current SGA threshold, “you can quickly get back on SSDI benefits” without going through a complete re-application.

The three-step program encourages disability benefits recipients to give returning to work their best shot because they’ve got nothing to lose. If returning to work goes well, the recipient will be in a better financial situation and if it doesn’t work out, they won’t be any worse off for having tried.

There are rules and regulations regarding returning to work and a recipient is not advised to do so without for seeking counsel from either an attorney experienced in Social Security disability benefits law or a representative at the SSA.

If you or a loved one has become disabled and would like assistance applying for Social Security disability benefits or appealing the denial of SSDI benefits, the Arizona Social Security disability law firm of Roeschke Law can help you at any phase of the process.

Call us to request a free consultation at 800-975-1866. From our offices in Phoenix, Tucson, and Tempe, we represent clients throughout Arizona in all areas of disability law. 

What Would Happen to Disability Benefits if Social Security was Privatized?

The Social Security Administration, a part of the federal government, not only oversees and administers retirement benefits to workers ready to kick back and enjoy their golden years, but it is also responsible for administering Social Security disability insurance (“SSDI”) and Supplemental Security Income (“SSI”) benefits to disabled people.

At various points in history, citizens have questioned whether their Social Security retirement benefits will be there for them when they are finally old enough to retire. Small, periodic adjustments in the FICA tax rates and gradual pushing back of the minimum retirement age have previously been effective in thwarting threats to the solvency of the trust fund from which Social Security retirement benefits is paid.

In today’s current climate, many American workers are skeptical about the Social Security system’s “long-term financial stability”, with only 37% reporting being “somewhat or very confident” that the system will continue to provide retirement benefits  “of at least equal value” to those received by current retirees. This sentiment has led to a renewal of the debate on whether Social Security should be privatized or whether other changes, like the historic go-to Band-Aid® of increasing the FICA tax rate and minimum retirement age should be employed to “save” the current system.

Social Security is funded through a FICA payroll tax on wages paid by workers and their employers. Part of that tax goes to the trust fund from which Social Security retirement benefits are paid, and another part goes to the trust fund from which Social Security Disability insurance benefits are paid. It should be noted that unlike SSDI work-based federal disability benefits, SSI– a means-based federal disability benefits program–is not funded through a payroll tax, but rather a general revenue tax.

Privatizing Social Security and would mean that workers would “make contributions to their own privately managed retirement-savings accounts,” instead of paying the Social Security payroll taxes as they do now.

Proponents for privatizing Social Security retirement benefits argue that the current system will not be able to stay afloat long-term because of a “virtual explosion” in the number of retirees which has begun and will continue with the baby boomer generation hitting retirement age. With insufficient numbers of current and foreseeable future workers paying into the system through payroll taxes to support the demand of the baby boomer’s retirement benefits, the system cannot continue on its present course and “will be unable to fully pay scheduled benefits by 2034 unless dramatic changes are made”.


Privatization proponents support in a “compulsory system of private retirement savings accounts for individuals” such as mandatory 401K plans which, assuming a good annual return, would leave retirees able to have “a reasonable retirement”. Privatization would give retirees the option to buy an annuity, dry down the account as needed, and leave the balance upon death to loved ones.

On the flip side, opponents of privatization say the current Social Security system is insurance that protects all workers and insured against lost earnings due to “old-age, disability, or death”. They argue a savings plan can’t protect against such unpredictable risks as “living to age 110, becoming disabled or dying prematurely, leaving dependent children” – – all risks which Social Security does protect.  

Critics of privatization point out investment risks of private savings plans, possibility of outliving those savings, high administrative costs of savings plans, high cost of private disability, life, and annuity policies and the risks of insurance companies going out of business as some reasons why privatization isn’t the answer. Social Security also pays benefits to spouses, divorced spouses, and dependent children “not only at retirement but also in the event of disability or death.” What would even a highly paid worker who becomes disabled unexpectedly at a young age survive on without the guaranteed benefits of Social Security – – a private savings plan that hasn’t had time to grow? Those wishing to save the current Social Security system argue that it could be done by requiring the wealthiest citizens to pay the same 6.2% contribution rate as minimum-wage workers rather than the 8/10 of 1% rate that those who earn $1 million or more contribute.

It remains to be seen whether Social Security will be “saved” or scrapped and what impact that will have on the disabled who rely on Social Security. At a minimum, it seems that workers would need to purchase expensive private disability insurance policies in addition to those mandated retirement account contributions. But what if those insurance companies go under?

If you are considering applying for SSDI benefits or SSI benefits, the Arizona disability attorneys at Roeschke Law LLC can help you at any step of the process, whether with the initial application or on appeal. Call us at 800-975-1866 to schedule a free consultation. Let us help you get the disability benefits you’re entitled to without delay. From our offices in Phoenix, Tucson, and Tempe, we represent clients throughout the state of Arizona.